Top Used Compact SUVs to Buy in Western New York

Top Used Compact SUVs to Buy in Western New York — Basil Family Dealerships

Buffalo and Western New York are pretty tricky places to drive. Sure, there’s the infamous winter weather, which makes vehicles with all-wheel drive nearly essential, but there are plenty of other considerations as well. Those include the variable terrain from the lakefront and urban freeways to the hilly climbs further inland, as well as the specific uses and preferences of the driver. Truly though, there’s no better way to merge each of these considerations than through a compact SUV, which offers reliability and durability in the worst conditions, the maneuverability and road feel of a car, and enough space for everyday needs — as well as a few beyond the everyday.

Four of the best compact SUVs are the Chevrolet Equinox, GMC Terrain, Ford Escape, and Nissan Rogue. Each is more than capable of performing admirably, though they do have slightly different strengths from one another, which makes it important to shop carefully, ensuring that you end up with your perfect vehicle. This primer, from Basil Family Dealerships, is a great starting point, and from there, feel free to browse our used vehicle listings, then contact us to schedule a test drive!


Chevrolet Equinox

Chevrolet Equinox

Best for:

  • Elite in-cabin technology
  • Striking body styling
  • Strong fuel economy

Love in-cabin technology? If so, the Chevrolet Equinox might be perfect for you, as it’s been consistently renowned for including the latest and greatest digital goodies across the years. For Equinoxes manufactured between 2018 and 2024, that means a seven or eight-inch (depending on the trim level) infotainment touchscreen, with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay capability and a slew of USB and SD card connections. Beginning with 2025 models, Chevy took things to the next level, including a pair of large screens and the ability to display navigation in the instrument panel, freeing up the 11.3-inch touchscreen for other endeavors. Speaking of “other endeavors,” the Equinox offers roughly 64 cubic feet of cargo capacity in any model year and about 30 with all seats in place, more than enough for most typical uses. Its exterior trademark is sleek lines and styling, though it also has some muscle to take on a Buffalo winter with available all-wheel drive.


GMC Terrain

GMC Terrain

Best for:

  • Storage versatility
  • Robust standard safety features
  • Renowned technology

Though the GMC Terrain is certainly no slouch on the tech side of things with a series of intuitive, well-designed touchscreen systems and an available Bose sound system on most model years, it truly makes its mark in terms of storage versatility. Though its bottom-line numbers (63.3 cubic feet maximum, 29.6 cubic feet with all seats in place on a representative 2024 Terrain) aren’t terribly different from the Equinox, it separates itself with a folding front passenger seat to accommodate items up to eight feet long, and several thoughtfully-designed storage bins. It also lives up to its name with available all-wheel drive, which becomes standard at most higher trim levels, along with a fantastic list of safety features. Though the specifics of that vary a bit from year to year, pre and post-collision safety systems, lane keep assist, and emergency braking assist are among the typical offerings.


Ford Escape

Ford Escape

Best for:

  • Available plug-in hybrid powertrain
  • Luxurious seating
  • Ample cargo space

One immediate separator for the Ford Escape is its wide selection of powertrains, including both mild hybrid and plug-in hybrid formats, making it ideal for those who place a premium on efficiency. In its most recent generation, spanning the 2020 through 2026 model years, the plug-in hybrid is a setup pushing 210 horsepower and offering up to 37 miles of all-electric range (as well as 40 combined miles per gallon* when the battery is drained). The conventional engines offer plenty of power as well, making for an incredibly smooth ride. Another highlight for the Escape is its seating, which offers well-shaped and heavily padded space for five, including 40.7 inches of legroom in the back, as well as available dual-zone climate control to keep everyone comfortable. Its tech and storage features stack up well with its General Motors rivals; in fact, its cargo space exceeds both, with a maximum of 65.4 cubic feet.


Nissan Rogue

Nissan Rogue

Best for:

  • Conventional fuel efficiency
  • Spacious-feeling cabin
  • Long list of standard features

It’s tough to beat the Nissan Rogue for fuel efficiency in a traditional gasoline engine, as most of its powertrains deliver north of 30 combined miles per gallon, including 32 on most front-wheel drive setups, and 31 when equipped with available all-wheel drive.* The vast majority of used Rogues fall into its third generation, covering the 2021 through 2026 model years, which were broadly renowned for airy-feeling cabins, thanks to large doors and windows, as well as a surprising level of luxury character and a sense of tremendous value for the cost. A 12.3-inch touchscreen, massive compared to peers of the era, was introduced in 2024 and helps center the Rogue’s impressive array of tech features, though the smaller screens standard before that refresh certainly get the job done as well. The Rogue also stands out for its cargo space, combining the best traits of the Terrain (versatility) and Escape (volume) to deliver more capacity than any small SUV has the right to claim.



*EPA Fuel Economy Estimates. Actual mileage may vary with driving conditions. Use for comparison only.